I’ll admit, I do love a good sports movie. I’ll watch films like A League of Their Own, Chariots of Fire, Bull Durham, or Field of Dreams anytime they come on TV – and they come on a lot. There is inherent drama in the game, and movies love to capture that drama. Biopics, too, of sport figures can be thrilling when done right. I loved watching Chadwick Boseman’s fierce control as Jackie Robinson in 42, or Kurt Russell as Herb Brooks, forging the 1980 USA Hockey team into Olympic Champions in Miracle, and I’ve lost track of how many times I’ve seen The Blind Side. While what happens on the playing field is important, often the story off the field is as or more compelling. Now, one of the greatest sports stories in the last 25 years finally makes it to the screen.
American Underdog tells the story of Kurt Warner and all that he had to endure to fulfill his dream of playing in the NFL. More than that, though, it’s the story of the crucible of adversity refining character. We meet Kurt (Zachary Levi) finally getting a chance to play college football at Northern Iowa State after sitting on the bench for 4 years. He has talent, though its rough and unrefined, and learning is a humbling experience – as well as a painful one with defense players attacking him. While accompanying a friend to a country and western bar, Kurt is captivated by one of the women line-dancing there. He doesn’t like country music, but he learns line-dancing so he can meet her, discovering her name is Brenda (Anna Paquin). When Kurt tries to arrange a date with her, Brenda puts him off, explaining she’s a divorced mother with two children, figuring that will be the end of his interest. Instead, he walks miles from the campus to where Brenda lives with her parents. He ends up bonding with Brenda’s special-needs son Zach (Hayden Zaller), giving Brenda confidence in him.
Between the end of college and joining the Rams, there are five long years of trials. An early chance with the Packers comes to naught, leading Kurt to get a job as a night stocker at a grocery store. When Brenda’s parents move to their retirement home in Arkansas, Kurt takes on the responsibility for Brenda and her kids while she’s studying to be a nurse, though they’re faced with brutal poverty. That’s alleviated a bit by the arrival of Jim Foster (Bruce McGill), the entrepreneur who created the Arena Football League and ran the Iowa Barnstormers. The team’s based in Des Moines, while Brenda’s attending school in Cedar Rapids a couple of hours away, leading to strains that almost destroy their relationship. But when tragedy strikes, it becomes a clarifying moment for Kurt. Even when the Rams recruit him, there’s adversity. Coach Dick
Vermeil (Dennis Quaid) is occupied with the whole team, while Offensive Coordinator Mike Martz (Chance Kelly) is brutal, not believing that an older Arena Football quarterback can master the complicated offense he’s designed. But the five years have made Kurt resilient, and when an injury opens the way for Kurt, he’s ready for his chance.
I lived in St. Louis during the 1999 miracle season when the Rams were the greatest show on turf. This was after they’d been an embarrassment to the town that was use to winning seasons for the baseball Cardinals and hockey Blues. During the year before, when Mark McGwire had his record-setting home run season (and essentially saved baseball after a strike had nearly ruined the league’s fan base), one Sunday afternoon the cheers from the ballpark were so loud they disrupted the Rams game a few blocks away. Against the brilliance of the Rams the next season, Warner’s story was often repeated, usually by color commentators shaking their heads. Yet American Underdog does a good job keeping the story real and grounded.
Much of the credit goes to Zachary Levi, who’s on a bit of a roll right now. I’d been a fan of his since his comedic spy turn on TV in “Chuck” early in his career. So often that can be the highpoint for an actor, but Levi kept working on TV and in pictures until (you could say) lightning struck with Shazam. He followed that up with an excellent supporting role on “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisal,” and IMDb has six projects for Levi listed in pre- or post-production. Anna Paquin had, of course, won an Oscar with her first movie role in The Piano, and there are many careers that have quickly gone downhill from such success. Paquin’s had a strong career, managing to grow from child roles into adulthood with the X-Men series, and taking the lead in HBO’s “True Blood.” She and Levi had good chemistry, as well as a deep feeling for the characters.
Directors Andrew and Jon Erwin have mostly done inspirational films, often tied to Christian recording artists (I Can Only Imagine, I Still Believe). With American Underdog, they go more for a straight bio-pic, and they don’t gloss over the conflicts between Kurt and Brenda that came close to sinking their relationship. In the end, the most overt statement of faith is left to Warner himself, with a clip of his testimony after winning the Super Bowl.
Kurt Warner has been rated at the best undrafted player ever in the history of the NFL. We tend sometimes to just look at the result. American Underdog shows all the grit, determination, pain, and sacrifice that it took to get to that result, which makes the triumph all the sweeter.