The Force Awakens: Discussion with Spoilers

Last week I published a review of Star Wars Episode 7: The Force Awakens though I worked hard to not give away any major plot points. One response I received, though, asked for the chance to discuss the movie, so I decided to do another post with the freedom to discuss the full film, spoilers and all, for those who have seen the movie. SO, IF YOU HAVE NOT SEEN THE MOVIE DO NOT READ THIS! Really – trust me. You want to experience this movie without any hints.

Now, for those of you who’ve seen the movie, I’ll outline several aspects of it that struck me. Please feel free to interact in the comments sections about your own reactions to The Force Awakens.

Right from the opening scenes, you could tell this wasn’t a Phantom Menace. That one began with almost a leisurely scene between Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon (even when they’re fighting droids), and then it goes downhill as soon as Jar Jar Binks enters the scene. Instead Force matches A New Hope with the dark Star Destroyer sliding across a moon until it completely blots it out. The dark side has come. Abrams had a perfect casting moment when he had Max Von Sydow do a cameo appearance as the person who gives Poe Dameron (Oscar Isaac) the clue to the location of Luke Skywalker. Von Sydow is about the only active actor left who was a contemporary of Alec Guinness. Abrams also echoed the introduction of Darth Vader with Kylo Ren walking down the ramp from the space ship.

I’d enjoyed John Boyega in Attack the Block and was pleased to see him as Finn. Finn adds nuance and depth to the story. The Imperial Storm Troopers have always been as anonymous as they were bad shots. Their aim has improved a little in Force Awakens – emphasis on “a little” – but Finn gives them a humanity they’ve never had before. Instead of blind obedience, Finn’s inner decency asserts itself when he refuses to shoot during the village massacre. He at first wants to run away – as Maz Kanata (Lupita Nyong’o) sees in his eyes – but he’s honorable enough to seek to get Poe’s droid back to the rebels. And after Ren grabs Rey, he switches from running away to running toward the danger.

Rey (Daisy Ridley) takes her place alongside Sarah Conner and Ripley (among others) as sci-fi’s kickass women. Abrams has always been talented at writing strong women, such as Sydney Briscoe in “Alias,” but he’s gone beyond that with Rey. Leia had a bit of this in the original trilogy, but she wasn’t as compelling as Luke, Han, or Darth. Here, though, Rey is front and center, and the final duel with Kylo Ren pays off the build of the plot.

Speaking of Ren, I was pleased that Abrams didn’t try to tease out his identity. From early in the film we know he’s Ben Solo, son of Han and Leia, but he’d been seduced by the dark side like his grandfather Anakin. Having the partially melted Vader mask is a great piece of imagery. The moment when he reveals his face to Rey was a shot of adrenalin. You expect the disfigurement of Anakin, but instead you have a handsome young man. It underlines that the scars of the dark side are not outwardly visible.

Using motion capture for Supreme Leader Snoke and Maz Kanata was a much better choice than the computer-generated Jar Jar Binks. Andy Serkis, who plays Snoke, is the leading actor for this effect, so it wasn’t surprising to have him cast as Snoke. Interestingly, the communication scenes that Ren and General Hux (Domhnall Gleason) have with Snoke mirror Darth Vader’s interview with the Emperor in The Empire Strkes Back, with the hologram image being enormous. As Serkis was expected, Lupita Nyong’o as Maz was a choice out of left field. You have one of the most beautiful women in film play a diminutive alien with fish-eye goggles, but she nails the character. Her scene with Rey also means that Force Awakens is the first Star Wars film (and one of the few sci-fi movies ever) that passes the Bechdel test.

There’s an interesting connection with the cast in that Oscar Isaac and Domhnall Gleason were two of three main actors in Ex Machina earlier this year. If you want to see how good they are, take a peek at that movie and then compare it to Force Awakens. Here, though, they never have a scene together.

I did enjoy BB-8, who is a worthy successor to R2D2 – and also a much faster droid. With all the running in the movie the stately pace of R2 wouldn’t have worked. A great moment was when Finn flashes BB the thumbs up sign and the droid responds with a lighter flame.

Abrams referenced the original trilogy in ways that both paid tribute to it as well as twisted our expectations. The first appearance of Kylo Ren, the removal of his mask, the attack on the planet killer, all mirror earlier scenes, but nowhere was that used to better effect than Han’s final scene with Ren. It takes place on a bridge over a chasm, just like the scene in Empire where Darth reveals he’s Luke’s father. Instead of the perverse paternal plea of Vader – “We can rule the universe side by side” – you have Han pleading for the restoration of his son. When Ren runs his lightsaber through his father, it’s a gut punch for Star Wars fans.

The very end of the movie could have been trimmed a bit – how many steps can a person climb and keep the interest of the audience? – but the wordless moment of connection between Luke and Rey is perfect. The indicators in the script point to Luke being her father, which means Rey experienced a similar fate as Luke, being separated from her family for most of her young life. (There are other theories out there about Rey, but until the next movie is released I’ll go with this one.)

Those are my thoughts. Please feel free to post your own responses and ideas below, or engage in a discussion. I’ll try to check the blog as often as possible to approve comments to facilitate the discussion. Go.



7 thoughts on “The Force Awakens: Discussion with Spoilers

  1. I am going to disagree with you about Rey being Luke’s daughter only because of the flashback scene. In that scene, we see the Millennium Falcon speeding away. i think it’s a greater possibility that she is related to Leia somehow. Possibly Ben’s twin. Twins do run in families and that would work in the mythology. Just my theory

  2. Michael…and in Lucas’ original stories, Jan and Leia did have twins…boy and girl. So I’m not ruling out that she’s Ren/Ben’s sister instead of cousin.

    And I know we’ve departed from canon with the sale to Disney and I’m oddly ok with that.

    Ultimately, Star Wars is the story of redemption though. So there are all kinds of theories that seem WAY out there but that I’m willing to entertain.

    For example, I read “what if Rey were actually another incarnation of Anakin?” They hint in the prequels that Anakin was a virgin birth of sorts. If Rey is Anakin come back to finish…it’s just a neat twist and makes the whole series a story of Anakin’s redemption.

    On that same vein what if Ben really isn’t dark at all and is simply trying to infiltrate the Sith to finish off Snoke. It’d mean that he was finishing Anakin’s work for good. He sacrifices Han (after asking “will you help me?”) in order to get closer to Snoke. That’s why he’s torn. (There’s a fan theory out there about that too.)

    By the way, that’d go back to Lucas’ stories and how Luke pretended to go dark to bring balance. Just another thought.

    Anyway, all that to say. THANK YOU! You made other excellent points but I had such a deep reaction to the assumption that Rey is Luke’s daughter that I distracted myself. 🙂

    AKA Titian Chick

  3. Yay, thank you David!!!
    Here goes. (I’m not a reviewer, just a fan so this will be no where near as organized or succinct as your review!!)

    My favorite bits in this movie were the introductions to each character … including the Millenium Falcon and the droids .. with what felt like just a little catch-breath when we saw our old friends, kind of an equivalent to the applause that used to greet the stars of a stage play or filmed-in-front-of-a-live-audience comedy or variety show.
    Loved seeing Harrison and Carrie interact. They may have gone thirty years without living in these characters’ skins, but they managed to bring all the youthful passion and the poignant regrets of adulthood, parenthood and some form of divorce together in amazingly nuanced performances. You could see the chemistry — and tension — shimmer off the screen.
    My least favorite bit… all that power Rey discovered she had, and she was a half-portion metal-scavenger on a random desert planet (that just happened to have been the scene of the last major battle), with no one knowing who she was and no clear indication how she ended up there? At least Luke had Old Ben Kenobi in the desert watching him from a distance, and his non-force-talented uncle and aunt raising him. Basic archetype/hero’s journey: You hide young Arthur Pendragon in a simple knight’s household, but Merlin knows where he is and contrives to see that he’s taught what he needs to know to rule his people when he comes of age. Side note; Maz Kanata is a brilliant interpretation of the Lady of the Lake, saving that famous blue lightsaber for the rightful wielder just like Excalibur 😉 The kindly old guy who gave the flashdrive to Poe, in spite of his allusion to being loyal to his Princess before she became a General, didn’t seem to have any connection to Rey. If it WASN”T coincidence that he was on Jakku to meet Poe, or that Poe came to Jakku to meet him, then something important apparently stayed on the cutting room floor. But let’s say that we’re all wrong, and she’s neither Ren’s twin sister nor Luke’s offspring. She still is Jedi-powerful. Surely Leia knows enough of the Force, even though she wasn’t fully trained in it as Luke was, to sense — and remark on — Rey’s latent ability the moment she meets her. Vader could feel the strength in Luke while piloting a Tie at a zillion miles an hour in hot pursuit of an entire squad of Xwings, right?

    Other little quibble…Han might not have believed in the Force 30-odd years ago, but he always had an innate sense of when something was going down. He had a strong feeling of self-preservation, and “I’ve got a bad feeling about this” became as much a cultural cliche as “beam me up Scotty”. *I* had a bad feeling about him going onto that bridge to meet Ben-Kylo over that chasm — why didn’t he? (Oh wait, maybe he couldn’t hear the musical score change key and get dark and ominous).

    On the plus side– this was the Star Wars Universe I’ve always loved and always wanted to live in (if the Shire of Middle-Earth wasn’t an option). Andy Serkis is not just the king of mo-cap, he’s also an incredible voice talent. I love that Rey and Finn ARENT falling in love at first sight but are dealing with the objectives first, foremost and last. And I can’t wait to see this again…and the next one..and the one after that!

    Looking forward to more on this thread 🙂

    • Good points, Sara, though in regard to Rey I think more will be introduced in the next film about her time on Jakku, and it could be that Lor San (Von Sydow) was her Ben Kenobi. Remember, Luke didn’t know much about Ben before the droids arrived.

      With Han, he did feel like a slightly older, slightly wiser, and more damaged version of his younger self.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s